Thursday, September 24, 2015
Friday, December 20, 2013
A poor muckraker
Ken Avidor has always fancied himself a 'skeptic' of Personal Rapid Transit, as well as an investigative 'muckraker.' Repeatedly he has called PRT a scam/hoax/etc.
But we can't help but notice that when the PRT NewsCenter exposes a real PRT fraud, Avidor says not one word about it.
Happy Holidays.
gPRT
Not even an Atta Boy
Posted by
Mr_Grant
at
12/20/2013 11:00:00 AM
1 comments
Labels: Meta
Monday, September 23, 2013
Not synonymous
Princeton Council heard testimony at their September 9 meeting from Kevin Wilkes, the Chair of the Alexander Street / University Place Transit Task Force. He reported that the possibility of a heavy rail extension of the Dinky Line to take it up to Palmer Square is no longer being considered. Use of Personal Rapid Transit (PRT) technology has also been excluded from further discussion. However, several other transport modes remain under discussion.Did we get that? "Considered." "Discussion." They are talking about the transit modes they could implement, and dropping some of those. What has been stopped about PRT is scoping --which, at this early stage, is basically just an on-paper technology assessment.
We don’t have the turning radius; we don’t have the ability to run the catenary lines up any street in town. We eliminated that as a possibility.
Update 1
So Ken has tried to learn from the above, posting this today (10/2/2013):
Hedging his bets, he calls the Amritsar PRT thingamajig a "Proposal."
Except the Amritsar PRT thingamabob has reached the stage of laying a foundation stone, selecting a vendor, and drawing up detailed plans. I'm afraid that takes the Amritsar PRT thingy past the rank of proposal, all the way to being a real project.*
The verdict:
Too bad, Ken.
* Although, the headline on the linked article is "Much-hyped Pod transit system for Amritsar may get scrapped" (emphasis added), so as of now it can't be said to have actually bitten the dust yet.
gPRT
Posted by
Mr_Grant
at
9/23/2013 10:55:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Fact Check, India, Man Out Of Time, Twitter, WORST EXPERT IN THE WORLD
Saturday, September 07, 2013
Who will rid me of this troublesome priest?
...is what Ken Avidor might have shouted, if he is familiar with Becket, upon reading this Avi-adoring reader comment on the recent Mountain View Voice article, Pod Cars have new champion in Silicon Valley (highlighting added):
Posted by Bill Hough, a resident of another community
on Sep 5, 2013 at 11:31 am
"Podcars or "Personal Rapid Transit" is an idea that's been around for decades yet never seems to actually get built or solve any real-world transportation problems. It basically combines the worst of both worlds: low vehicle capacity of the private automobile with the expensive infrastructure of a fixed guideway transit system.
This topic has been discussed at length. I recommend a couple of articles on the Light Rail Now website.
First, there's "Let's Get Real About Personal Rapid Transit" by Ken Avidor at Web Link
Avidor points out that, "PRT has a solid 30-year record of failure. Its main purpose in recent years seems to have been to provide a cover enabling its proponents to spread disinformation about real, workable transit systems. Except for the occasional laboratory-scale prototype, PRT actually "exists" largely in computerized drawings, in promotional brochures, and in cute, ever-successful animated simulations on the internet."
"The unsubstantiated claims of PRT proponents are always presented in the present tense as if the system is a proven success ... which, of course, it certainly is not. Promoters never seem to fail to bash real transit, such as light rail (LRT), as "old fashioned technology". Sadly, the media rarely check the veracity of PRT publicity and propaganda."
A longer, more technical article is "Personal Rapid Transit – Cyberspace Dream Keeps Colliding With Reality" and can be found here: Web Link
"Despite the persistent and fervent claims of its promoters, repeated attempts to implement a working PRT system, even in very small-scale scenarios, have invariably failed. Not a single PRT plan, during these promotional efforts over the past 40 years or more, has seen successful implementation even in a small test application, much less a major, heavy-duty, citywide rapid transit application. Early would-be PRT installations, such as the AirTrans system at Dallas-Ft. Worth Regional Airport, and the PRT at West Virginia University at Morgantown, eschewed any attempt to provide true PRT-style, small-vehicle, customized origin-destination service, and were implemented in effect as line-haul automated guideway transit (AGT) peoplemover systems with some innovative features (such as offline stations)."
And finally, the good folks at Light Rail Now have put up a helpful list of links to various Monorail, PRT, AGT, and "Gadget Transit" Analyses at Web Link
Council member Mike Kasperzak and the rest of the City Council need to realize that "podcars" are the latest manifestation of the PRT fad which has been around for decades yet never seems to get built.
Ken must have been so upset. I mean come on -- poor guy. Look at it from his perspective. He hides all of his hateblogs from the general public and enjoys a summer of peace and quiet, only to have this "Bill Hough, a resident of another community," remind everybody of the anti-PRT propaganda he helped write, but posted on websites not under his control.
"Hough" does make for fun reading though. It's as if zero time has passed since those execrable documents were written -- 'Heathrow Pod? Masdar PRT? Suncheon Ecotrans? What are they?'
Obviously the guy doesn't read the Laffable Luddite Chronicles or Get There Fast.
gPRT
Leave Ken Avidor alone! You're lucky he performs for you bastards!!!
Posted by
Mr_Grant
at
9/07/2013 11:11:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: California, Debunking, Humor
Saturday, August 31, 2013
Hot Potato - Update 2
It used to be that when Minnesota anti-PRT propagandist Ken Avidor wanted to smear pod transit as a right wing conspiracy, all he had to do was trot out one of his state's Republicans who had said or done something supportive in the legislature.
Leaving aside the issue of why Minnesota was able to produce, elect and nurture whackjobs like Michele Bachmann and Mark Whoever despite the (best?) efforts of Ken the Dump Blogger, we have to remember that the pro-PRT community for many years was limited to one citizens group with limited resources.
Republicans were generally anti-light rail and therefore seen as the path of least resistance, and they became a focus of pro-PRT efforts. This was a mistake, especially since it turned out there were plenty of Democrats willing to offer bills on PRT.
My point is that it was easy for Ken to trot out Krazy Eyes and Slappy whenever (and that was often) he needed to dismiss PRT as fringe.
But he can't do that now, now that there are Heathrow pods, Masdar City PRT and Suncheon pods in operation, and plenty of non-Republicans are interested.
He can't do it, but it doesn't mean he won't try.
Recently Ken tried to use his old technique of linking a politician to 'pod people,' hoping to achieve shaming. But this time the politician is Jim Oberstar, who is giving the keynote at this fall's Podcar City conference at George Mason University.
Oberstar is no small-time loon like the aforementioned duo.* For one thing, he's a Democrat. And in his 1975-2011 House career he amassed enormous gravitas on transportation issues. He was only Chairman of the Transportation and Infrastructure Committee. In fact, Oberstar is an avid cyclist and promoted creation of bike trails during his long career. You'd think Ken would remember that. Awkward.
| Jim Oberstar doesn't need Ken Avidor's approval. |
Will Avidor attack Oberstar more as the Podcar City conference gets closer? It would be the stupid thing to do, but -- Nah; I think he'll drop it.
^* UPDATE 1 -- Ken quotes us out of context again! He tried to slime Oberstar, now tries to make it look like we did it.
UPDATE 2: James Oberstar, 1934-2014
gPRT
Get it together Ken, you're barely trying
Posted by
Mr_Grant
at
8/31/2013 11:43:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: The Smears, Twitter
Tuesday, July 30, 2013
The Turd Stirs
Phil Krinkie, a Republican who cares so much about PRT that he hasn't said anything about it in seven years, has entered the race* to succeed Michele Bachmann in Minnesota's 6th congressional district.
So out of all the important issues facing the district and our nation, what is the ONE thing Minnesota anti-PRT propagandist (semi-retired) Ken Avidor decided to tell his Twitter followers about Krinkie?
You guessed it:
Ken seems to think that there are simply no remaining issues in this race other than -- what a coincidence -- Ken's obsession.
gPRT
* "Phil Krinkie joins GOP race to succeed Bachmann," St. Paul Pioneer Press, July 20, 2013
Posted by
Mr_Grant
at
7/30/2013 09:08:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Bachmannage and Discipline, Politics, Twitter
Wednesday, April 10, 2013
I Cannot Comment
Thanks to reader "Not THE Harry Harrison" for alerting me to this:
At first I thought maybe this was Ken's extreeeme attempt to deprive me of material. But no, it's about all of his blogs, not just Dump Bachmann:
At first reading it is tantalizing for what he doesn't say -- not I don't know, or There are technical difficulties, or even That god-damn Blogger. What it sounds like to a reasonable person is I've been told to keep my mouth shut.
And here is his explanation for public consumption:
Let's note that in general "I cannot comment" is a very legalistic expression. People say it when they're in trouble. They say it when arriving at the police station to assist with their inquiries.
Maybe litigation is occurring, or is in the pipeline, about something or things Ken has written in one of his blogs. Something serious and with merit, otherwise those blogs would still be up and Ken would be blogging about it. Of course, libel can be libel even if distribution is limited.
This is the "case" mentioned by AnitaMaria, but I can't believe that has any merit, coming as it does from a right wing whackjob. I certainly wouldn't pull down my blogs in face of a nuisance suit from such a quarter (unless I had written something that -- oh never mind).
Or maybe Ken simply doesn't understand that to be of value an archive needs to be accessible to would-be researchers. ANY researchers. Otherwise your archive enters the realm of conspiracy theory-style 'secret knowledge.' Yes, Stupidity would be the simple explanation.
More later (I suspect).
I suppose I COULD treat it as a victory
Posted by
Mr_Grant
at
4/10/2013 01:06:00 PM
1 comments
Labels: Blogging, Retirement, Twitter
Tuesday, March 12, 2013
Nothing Meaningful
Mock Journalist, Part XIII
The new Ken Avidor blog post is the work of a lazy, lazy man.
You can tell from the title: Was Minnesota Personal Rapid Transit Huckster Run Out of Fayetteville, Georgia on " a Greased Rail" After "Press Release Hoax"? (PRT Moondoggie, 3/12) The question mark at the end means 'I have no idea.' Lazy.
The story is about the foot-in-mouth attempts by the JPods PRT company to secure an installation deal with the city of Fayetteville, Georgia. We relayed this sorry excuse for transit development starting a month ago at the NewsCenter (see 2/13) -- the linked stories show how JPods basically counted its chickens before they were hatched.
The overview is that JPods accidentally or on purpose released a press statement prematurely claiming Fayetteville had agreed to host the company's first pod installation. When it found out, the city council was not pleased, and the gambit (or mistake or misunderstanding or whatever it was) appears to have been pivotal in the council decision to not let JPods build on/over public rights of way. Build it on private land, they decided.
Which is absolutely the correct decision in this case, simply because JPods has zero track record it can cite to reassure a community it can bring off a successful project. JPods wanted Fayetteville to be the guinea pig for a pod design with no prototype, no testing results, no regulatory sign-off, no project team, no manufacturing capability, no supply chain. In effect, JPods wanted Fayetteville to host a testing facility -- and that is not the job of local government, even if (as JPods claims) the project funding was to be 100% private. The public still 'pays' by allowing use of public ROW, and in any negative impacts on overall transportation and land use.
That Ken gets the story right this time is due only to the fact that he sat back and waited for the Fayetteville media, the NewsCenter, and the Transport-Innovators Google Group to do the work of information gathering as well as criticism.
And he concludes today's entry by telling any public officials who might be reading (I suppose it's possible), "If you're wondering whether PRT is a boondoggle or not, Google is your best friend" -- an unwitting admission that Ken Avidor adds nothing meaningful to the coverage or discussion of personal rapid transit.
But you knew that.
Posted by
Mr_Grant
at
3/12/2013 11:23:00 AM
2
comments
Labels: Blogging
Tuesday, January 29, 2013
Non-video video
It's 2013!
The Laffable Luddite is so desperate to find bad PRT news, he's posted audio of a Minnesota legislative meeting with new transportation commissioner Charles Zelle. The remarks are actually neutral and do not result in any policy statements about PRT in Minnesota (i.e., pod transit is still going nowhere in the state). But it's not negative toward PRT either, so Ken has to call it "PRT rears it's [sic] ugly head", complete with obligatory Ken typo.
Also: Ken's blog post on the topic, slamming both of the transportation commissioners (Zelle is second) appointed by Democratic Governor Mark Dayton. PRT continues to exist for Avidor only in a conservative Republican bubble he has constructed, ignoring nonideological PRT activity around the world.
gPRT
Posted by
Mr_Grant
at
1/29/2013 01:32:00 PM
0
comments
Labels: Politics, WORST EXPERT IN THE WORLD
Friday, December 07, 2012
Sense of proportion
"King Kong was only three foot six inches tall."Scale. It's always good to put things in their proper scale. Context, if you will.
Peter O'Toole to Steve Railsback
The Stunt Man
1980, 20th Century Fox
The history of this blog is replete with examples of us pointing out when Ken Avidor ignores or omits context, all the better to incorrectly portray Personal Rapid Transit technology. I bet he thought he could sneak two non-contextual photos by us in his November 15 post, Suncheon Bay Vectus "PRT" Revealed to NOT be Personal Rapid Transit (Berther, 11/15). We could probably call it a Screen Play -- a Big Lie, 'Suncheon PRT stations aren't offline', running interference for this:
Two pictures in which there is nothing familiar to impart a sense of scale. Sure, thought Ken, I'll just call them 'massive.' It's not like anyone can prove otherwise -- it's all the way over in Korea.
He thought wrong.
An examination of the photo of Station One and Depot in the official Vectus PDF does contain a good clue about scale: workers on the ground.
Let's propose those workers are 5'7." That would make the station platform only about 28 feet above the ground. And the station roof only about 40 feet above the ground.
For even better sense of scale, behold these recently released photos showing a rather compact Suncheon Station 2:
![]() |
| PRT Consulting |
![]() |
| PRT Consulting |
![]() |
| PRT Consulting |
It's official: Vectus lists 'typical' guideway width as 1400mm (4.6 ft. Ref: page 23 here). But the vehicles are 2100mm/6.9 ft wide (p.22), so the little pods are actually wider than the "massive" guideway.
gPRT Massive Liar
Posted by
Mr_Grant
at
12/07/2012 10:35:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Debunking, Korea, Photo Analysis, WORST EXPERT IN THE WORLD
Thursday, November 15, 2012
Berther
Laffable Luddite again displays ignorance of basic PRT concepts
I think we've pretty well established how Ken Avidor is the Worst Expert In The World when it comes to anything to do with PRT. So his new blog post "Suncheon Bay Vectus "PRT" Revealed to NOT be Personal Rapid Transit" can best be described as maintaining his pattern.
Avidor writes as follows (pay attention to what he has put in bold, they are not in the original):
The Vectus October update (PDF) has a preview of their much-ballyhooed Suncheon Bay project in Korea.
Station Two is currently under construction and due to be completed by the end of December 2012. Both stations will feature in-line berths, platform screen doors and touch screen passenger information/destination selection facilities.According to the Wikipedia PRT article which is mostly written by fans of PRT, offline stations are a defining characteristic of PRT:
In PRT designs, vehicles are sized for individual or small group travel, typically carrying no more than 3 to 6 passengers per vehicle.[1] Guide ways are arranged in a network topology, with all stations located on sidings, and with frequent merge/diverge points. This approach allows for nonstop, point-to-point travel, bypassing all intermediate stationsSo Vectus is just another monorail/people-mover that exist in airports, amusement parks etc. all over the world. Not the revolution in transportation we were promised, not "faster, cheaper, better" than conventional transit modes.
He really thinks he has something here, and sinks his teeth in. Except he's comparing apples and oranges: the fact is a PRT station is offline, but its berths can be either inline or not inline.
Nomenclature review:
- A station is where multiple pods can park to load and unload passengers; it is offline on a siding so vehicles going to other stations can bypass it.
- The positions where pods park are berths; they can be sawtoothed where pods park at an angle so they can pass each other in the station, or inline (!!!) where pods park nose to tail.
Here is a PRT station at Masdar City:
![]() |
Sawtoothed: Berths angled, not inline. Station is offline.
|
![]() |
Berths nose-to-tail, or inline. Station is still offline.
|
You choose: Ken Avidor doesn't understand what an inline berth is, or knows what it is but has decided to deliberately confuse it* with inline stations.
Update 1 (11/16): Martin Pemberton, Vectus director of Sales & Marketing, has confirmed to NewsCenter that the Suncheon stations are indeed offline --
Maybe some confusion in terminology. By 'in-line' we mean one behind the other. The stations are 'off-line' from the main track, ie. in siding as you call them.
The clock to see how long it takes Ken to retract his post starts... now.
By the way, while the official definition of PRT calls for offline stations, a demonstration system with only two stations (like Vectus at Suncheon) wouldn't need stations to be on sidings. A trip from Station One that bypassed Station Two would end up -- where? I invite Ken to try to fill in the blank.
Basically, there is no need at Suncheon to bypass a station. Doubt could be cast on Vectus should they ever offer inline stations in a larger, multi-station system. But we know they are capable of offline stations. An offline station was a feature of the Vectus test facility in Sweden, which received government safety clearance.
![]() |
| Uppsala, Sweden. Vectus pod enters offline guideway. |
^ * i.e., lie
P.S. Ken also has a second post today, in which he declares:
"elections have consequences... the [Nov. 6, 2012] election slams the door on any chance of public funding for PRT projects"
For proof he cites a quote from 2011 by one Minnesota legislator who is skeptical of PRT, who is the new chair of the senate transportation committee. And the quote contains no vow about door-slamming, it's all an Avidor prediction; we know how accurate he is about predictions.
In short, elections would have consequences for PRT in Minnesota -- had PRT been an issue in any Minnesota election contest, which it was not (sorry Ken, you mentioning it doesn't count).
At any rate, no future public funding for PRT projects in Minnesota represents no change from the past. Ken is celebrating no change.
gPRT
PRTher, rhymes with Birther
Posted by
Mr_Grant
at
11/15/2012 10:13:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Debunking, Korea, Man Out Of Time, Wikipedia, WORST EXPERT IN THE WORLD
Thursday, August 30, 2012
Terrifying Misrepresentation!!!
Today Ken Avidor the Laffable Luddite is back, and he's in fine Jell-O-like form.
"VIDEO: Heathrow T5 Personal Rapid Transit Pod Customer Service: " Truly Shameless""Video"! "Shameless"! "Failure can happen"! "Especially terrifying"!
Pod promoters always downplay the possibility of failures for PRT. The fact is failure can happen with any mechanical system. What is especially terrifying for a passenger is to experience a failure without any human available to explain what is going on. …
Source
Ken then shows you the video. Of a man terrifyingly* stuck at the Terminal 5 pod STATION, trying to speak with Customer Service but not getting satisfaction, which "PRT is a Joke IS A JOKE" is certain must never happen in any other everyday situation in the whole wide world already.
![]() |
| OH THE HUMANITY! Frame from the terrifying video of the terrifying Heathrow Terminal 5 pod station. At any time they might have walked next door for a snack (although I hear Gordon Ramsay kitchens can be nightmares) while the problem was being resolved. |
"Pod promoters" don't really "downplay" failures, either. In fact, they speak and write extensively on how they try to design their system with backup components to reduce the odds of failure. Maybe that makes them sound overconfident, but they certainly don't "downplay."
In addition, it's hard to make sense of the source blogger's complaint:
We had to listen to a voice hiding behind the screen, who after a while stopped picking up the help phone also.
As though he expected an airport representative to be crouched behind the little kiosk. We don't even know why the pods appeared to be not in operation.
But the blogger does make it clear that:
Its [sic] not bad that it failed, because these things do fail, what was worse was that they refused to send anybody down for the 20 minutes it was out of order.
The complaint was about Customer Service (the human factor), NOT the Ultra PRT technology. And at 20 minutes in duration, a decidedly minor complaint.
Verdict:
Update 1: Robert Llewellyn's Fully Charged -- "About 90%" of Heathrow Pod users have pushed the :) button.
^ *So terrified he had the presence of mind to record the video
gPRT
Posted by
Mr_Grant
at
8/30/2012 02:04:00 PM
0
comments
Labels: Blogging, Fact Check, WORST EXPERT IN THE WORLD, YouTube
Saturday, July 21, 2012
Epoch, In Your Face-level defeat for the Laffable Luddite
Posted by
Mr_Grant
at
7/21/2012 12:54:00 PM
0
comments
Labels: Real Life, Technology
Thursday, July 05, 2012
Hazy
Trivandrum: Infrastructure Kerala Ltd (INKEL) had brought up the idea of pod-cars around the same time when monorail was being pushed as a Mass Rapid Transit System for the city. As of now, monorails do not appear likely as the government is waiting for E Sreedharan's report on the feasibility of Trivandrum to have a metro rail system. And the future of pod-cars seems hazy as well.. . .While INKEL came up with the idea, NATPAC was given the task of conducting a feasibility study regarding the project."The feasibility study has been conducted and the report has been submitted to INKEL," informed T Elangovan, Head, Traffic and Transport Department, NATPAC. "Now it is upto [sic] them to submit the project report."He refused to comment on the conclusion of the report and only said: "The study was conducted for the 7 kilometer stretch between Vellayambalam and East Fort; it wasn't a study on how the pod-car project would be implemented but merely if the pod-car project is feasible or not."
Posted by
Mr_Grant
at
7/05/2012 06:32:00 PM
0
comments
Labels: Fact Check, India, Twitter, WORST EXPERT IN THE WORLD
Friday, May 04, 2012
Three little words
Posted by
Mr_Grant
at
5/04/2012 07:28:00 PM
0
comments
Labels: Blogging, California
Saturday, March 31, 2012
Possibly the funniest Laffable Luddite post...
...Since the last one! Ken Avidor's headline BLARES --
"Seattle Transportation Examiner.com Reporter [sic] Not Reporting His Opposition to Recent Seattle Personal Rapid Transit Proposal"
Not reporting on it, but quietly whispering his opposition on his personal blog.
![]() |
The Laffable Luddite says:
"He's covering monorail!"
"He's NOT covering monorail!
|
For some reason, Ken has a bug up his butt about my not reporting it at Examiner.com, as though some massive pipeline of Seattle Transportation News has been filtered to omit mention of the Great PRT Conspiracy.
News Flash -- I don't report anything on Examiner.com anymore, not in over TWO years, which was when I decided Examiner to be pretty much a joke as a citizen journalism umbrella.
My material is still there, it's still damn good stuff, but I haven't been adding to it, and I won't be.
Examiner doesn't really vet anything anyone writes. Content-wise there is no difference reading an Examiner-branded blog as opposed to something on Blogger or Tumblr -- quality depends on the author, being part of Examiner adds no value. And so in the last couple of years Examiner has become, in my opinion, a home for a lot of right wing nutjobs. Why would I want to be part of that brand?
I wouldn't, so I don't and I'm not.
Why has Ken Avidor decided to obsess about Examiner? I don't know and really don't care -- although I am amused.
If you want to know you could ask him -- if he allowed "PRT Moondoggie" readers to post comments.
Ken also writes
David Gow has finally acknowledged the existence of the PRT proposal for his city on his Get There Fast website's news page, with this comment:
Get There Fast takes no position on this proposal.
revealing (yet again) that he has absolutely no idea what he's talking about. I'm designer and admin for GetThereFast.org, but it's not 'mine.' It is run by a Seattle-area committee as an advocacy/community outreach website about PRT. Therefore MY editorial voice is not present on the page of news links. That GTF takes no position on the CenTran monorail proposal (again, I covered it here) is simply a statement of fact, and we want to stay out of what is, essentially, a political campaign.
As for "finally" acknowledging the existence of the "PRT proposal," I want to extend my apologies to Ken. New posts of news on GTF can lag because it often takes me a while to get to it, since I give PRT NewsCenter most of my time.
Although, Ken, my not having enough time for GTF is really your fault. All your anti-PRT idiocy creates tons of work for me here at "PRT Is a Joke IS A JOKE."
I suppose I should acknowledge the possibility that Avidor thinks he is Valiantly Taking The Fight To The Enemy On His Home Turf. But the way he's gone about it comes across as 'Don't cover PRT your way, cover it MYYYY way.'
Ken, I'm telling you this as a friend -- get some help for the OCD.
Allow comments, Ken! Cluck cluck bawk bawk BAWK!
gPRT
Posted by
Mr_Grant
at
3/31/2012 05:01:00 PM
0
comments
Labels: Blogging, Man Out Of Time, OCD

























